Transmission Question
Re: Transmission Question
Hi BEEK, can you say exactly which bearings are spinning when the tranny is in neutral with the clutch pedal out? Then I can cross reference them to the Haynes manual and see exactly where they are in the trans, that would really help. Then If I remove the potential culprits and take them to the engineering shop they should be able to test each bearing for me, thats my plan
Keith
Keith
-
- Posts: 1833
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:45 pm
- Your car is a: 1975 Spider
- Location: clermont fl
Re: Transmission Question
personally at this point, i would take every bearing and check them all. you have to dissasemble the whole trans anyway
Automotive Service Technology Instructor (34 year Fiat mechanic)
75 spider , 6 Lancia Scorpions, 2018 Abarth Spider, 500X wifes, 500L 3 82 Zagatos. 82 spider 34k original miles, 83 pininfarina, 8 fiat spider parts cars
son has 78 spider
75 spider , 6 Lancia Scorpions, 2018 Abarth Spider, 500X wifes, 500L 3 82 Zagatos. 82 spider 34k original miles, 83 pininfarina, 8 fiat spider parts cars
son has 78 spider
Re: Transmission Question
My god, the thoughts of removing all those gears and syncro hymmmmm
Keith
Keith
Re: Transmission Question
Hi guys,
One further thought, what noise is to be expected from the transmission, afterall the majority of parts are 32 years old, the only way I can describe the noise I hear is it sound exactly like the sound you get from a skate board wheel . The faster you spin it the more the sound increases. This sound best describes what I hear in neutral. And if you pivture this sound in your mind, could it not also be explained by the gears of the two shafts meshing at the different speeds?
As said earlier when in neutral the input and lay shaft and associated gears and bearings are spinning in relation to the crank speed, so pleanty of moving parts so bearing in mind the age of the transmission and wear should there not be some noise expected, I Really dont know how this tranny ran before I had it rebuilt so dont have anything to compare it to but should I expect it to run quiet, do yours run silent like in a modern car? plus maybe I have been using too thin oil.
Not trying to convince myself not to do the bearings but just trying to rule out all possibilities so I dont replace bearings etc only to find that the noise is just down to wear and tear.
Could this noise be related to the clutch throw out/release bearing?
When I fitted the new pilot bearing into the crank / flywheel I just pushed it into place, is that correct or should I have applied some sort of locktite? could the outer race of that be spinning and causing the noise I describe?
Can I please ask those kind enough to reply to my posts to reply to the entire post if you can because sometimes people comment on one little bit of the post and I need to keep revisiting items that dont get answered.
Regards
Keith
One further thought, what noise is to be expected from the transmission, afterall the majority of parts are 32 years old, the only way I can describe the noise I hear is it sound exactly like the sound you get from a skate board wheel . The faster you spin it the more the sound increases. This sound best describes what I hear in neutral. And if you pivture this sound in your mind, could it not also be explained by the gears of the two shafts meshing at the different speeds?
As said earlier when in neutral the input and lay shaft and associated gears and bearings are spinning in relation to the crank speed, so pleanty of moving parts so bearing in mind the age of the transmission and wear should there not be some noise expected, I Really dont know how this tranny ran before I had it rebuilt so dont have anything to compare it to but should I expect it to run quiet, do yours run silent like in a modern car? plus maybe I have been using too thin oil.
Not trying to convince myself not to do the bearings but just trying to rule out all possibilities so I dont replace bearings etc only to find that the noise is just down to wear and tear.
Could this noise be related to the clutch throw out/release bearing?
When I fitted the new pilot bearing into the crank / flywheel I just pushed it into place, is that correct or should I have applied some sort of locktite? could the outer race of that be spinning and causing the noise I describe?
Can I please ask those kind enough to reply to my posts to reply to the entire post if you can because sometimes people comment on one little bit of the post and I need to keep revisiting items that dont get answered.
Regards
Keith
Re: Transmission Question
Hi Guys, why have all the helpful comments dried up? Please comment on my last post.
keith
keith
- fiatmike124
- Posts: 56
- Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2012 7:07 pm
- Your car is a: 1981 Spider 2000
- Location: Thousand Oaks, CA
Re: Transmission Question
Since you are now talking about 32 year old parts, I'm a little confused as to what you mean by rebuilt. It is very likely to be a bad bearing and probably the input shaft bearing. It cannot be the pilot or release bearing because they are not spinning in neutral with clutch engaged. The outer and inner race of the pilot bearing are turning together with the crank and input shaft. As mentioned above, the trans need to be disassembled so everything should be inspected anyway. Until then, it's all speculation as to the exact cause of the noise.
Mike
1981 Fiat Spider 2000
2011 BMW 328i Coupe
2001 Mitsubishi Eclipse GT
2003 Yamaha V-Star 650
1981 Fiat Spider 2000
2011 BMW 328i Coupe
2001 Mitsubishi Eclipse GT
2003 Yamaha V-Star 650
Re: Transmission Question
Thanks Mike,
Soild answers.
When I said rebuilt that was bearings and syncros, the gears etc were all perfect according to the engineer shop.
I still have a feeling that the angle that I had the tranny sitting at in the car is responsible for causing the premature bearing failure. Assuming it is the bearing(s)
Is there a better book than the Haynes manual to describe the stripdown and rebuild or info I can download, I know it has been said that with common sense it is straight forward to work on the tranny but I would just like to be prepared before starting because the haynes manual is as much use as a chocolate fire guard. It is info on how to examine the parts / tolerances etc that would help.
Regards
keith
Soild answers.
When I said rebuilt that was bearings and syncros, the gears etc were all perfect according to the engineer shop.
I still have a feeling that the angle that I had the tranny sitting at in the car is responsible for causing the premature bearing failure. Assuming it is the bearing(s)
Is there a better book than the Haynes manual to describe the stripdown and rebuild or info I can download, I know it has been said that with common sense it is straight forward to work on the tranny but I would just like to be prepared before starting because the haynes manual is as much use as a chocolate fire guard. It is info on how to examine the parts / tolerances etc that would help.
Regards
keith
- seabeelt
- Patron 2019
- Posts: 1614
- Joined: Tue Feb 19, 2008 4:22 pm
- Your car is a: Fiat Spider - 1971 BS1
- Location: Tiverton, RI
Re: Transmission Question
The tranny repair manual is available on line, I believe. http://car-service-manuals.com/catalog/ ... ansmission
If this doesnt work, shoot me a PM with your email.
R/
If this doesnt work, shoot me a PM with your email.
R/
Michael and Deborah Williamson
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
Re: Transmission Question
Thanks Seabeelt,
That manual has a lot more information than Haynes, much obliged. I will read through before I start.
Thanks to everyone else that took part in this thread, I will let you know what I find when I open the tranny
Keith
That manual has a lot more information than Haynes, much obliged. I will read through before I start.
Thanks to everyone else that took part in this thread, I will let you know what I find when I open the tranny
Keith
- seabeelt
- Patron 2019
- Posts: 1614
- Joined: Tue Feb 19, 2008 4:22 pm
- Your car is a: Fiat Spider - 1971 BS1
- Location: Tiverton, RI
Re: Transmission Question
You are welcome. There are some photos here from when I rebuilt mine.
http://s198.photobucket.com/user/seabee ... 3915505437
I have more, but thats all thats posted on the site
r/
http://s198.photobucket.com/user/seabee ... 3915505437
I have more, but thats all thats posted on the site
r/
Michael and Deborah Williamson
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
Re: Transmission Question
Thanks again Seabeelt,
When I start if I have any problems or questions is it ok to PM you.
Regards
keith
When I start if I have any problems or questions is it ok to PM you.
Regards
keith
- seabeelt
- Patron 2019
- Posts: 1614
- Joined: Tue Feb 19, 2008 4:22 pm
- Your car is a: Fiat Spider - 1971 BS1
- Location: Tiverton, RI
Re: Transmission Question
More than welcome
R/
R/
Michael and Deborah Williamson
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
1971 Spider -Tropie’ - w screaming IDFs
1971 Spider - Vesper -scrapped
1979 Spider - Seraphina - our son's car now sold
1972 Spider - Tortellini- our son's current
- blurple124
- Posts: 393
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 3:46 pm
- Your car is a: 1978 Fiat 124 Spider
Re: Transmission Question
Well I think I may be in for a rebuild at some point in the future, but if I can do some work to buy myself some time, I might.
I need help identifying another noise with my tranny - a much worse one.
Under engine braking, gears 1,2,3, and 5 make a horrendous grinding noise. Fourth is quiet as a mouse and none pop out of gear. Furthermore, all gears are relatively quiet as long as the engine is applying the load to the transmission. No noise during engagement, either. If it is in gear and I let off, though, it makes a noise that causes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
I am still learning how these transmissions work, but maybe this information is enough to figure out which parts are going bad.
I need help identifying another noise with my tranny - a much worse one.
Under engine braking, gears 1,2,3, and 5 make a horrendous grinding noise. Fourth is quiet as a mouse and none pop out of gear. Furthermore, all gears are relatively quiet as long as the engine is applying the load to the transmission. No noise during engagement, either. If it is in gear and I let off, though, it makes a noise that causes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
I am still learning how these transmissions work, but maybe this information is enough to figure out which parts are going bad.
Charlie
1978 Fiat 124 Spider 1800 - Antonia
1997 Jeep Wrangler TJ Sport
1978 Fiat 124 Spider 1800 - Antonia
1997 Jeep Wrangler TJ Sport
Re: Transmission Question
Wow blurple124, I thought I had problems but they seem pretty small compared to the the stuff you have going on inside your tranny, unfortunately I too am learning so cant help but I have no doubts that the guys on here will point you in the right direction, although if I honest, based on your symptoms I dont think your going to like what they are going to say, good luck
Keith
Keith
- blurple124
- Posts: 393
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 3:46 pm
- Your car is a: 1978 Fiat 124 Spider
Re: Transmission Question
Yea, I'm going to have some fun with it.
I seem to get the most noise from the gears when I am in the rev-range for that speed. i.e. going 40 miles/hour in fifth and letting off of the throttle doesn't make too much noise, but the grinding seems to skip. If I do that at 60 mph, it is a steady grind.
In other news, the syncro for second is shot, but I don't need help with that one! haha.
So tranny rebuild. New bearings, seals, syncros and springs? Or do I only replace what I need to?
I seem to get the most noise from the gears when I am in the rev-range for that speed. i.e. going 40 miles/hour in fifth and letting off of the throttle doesn't make too much noise, but the grinding seems to skip. If I do that at 60 mph, it is a steady grind.
In other news, the syncro for second is shot, but I don't need help with that one! haha.
So tranny rebuild. New bearings, seals, syncros and springs? Or do I only replace what I need to?
Charlie
1978 Fiat 124 Spider 1800 - Antonia
1997 Jeep Wrangler TJ Sport
1978 Fiat 124 Spider 1800 - Antonia
1997 Jeep Wrangler TJ Sport